Comparing Team Fortress 2 and Overwatch Art Direction
Events
Subscribe:  iCal  |  Google Calendar
1, Jul — 1, Aug
San Diego US   19, Jul — 23, Jul
Torino IT   25, Jul — 29, Jul
Shanghai CN   3, Aug — 7, Aug
Vancouver CA   12, Aug — 17, Aug
Latest comments

Um....holodeck anyone?. This is exciting stuff!

by Do My Programming Language Homework
1 hours ago

I Loved The Way You Discuss The Topic Great Work Thanks For The Share. https://www.progassignments.com

Why not? I'm a programmer by heart and I'd rather spend few days making solution which will turn hours of mundane work into minutes where you can actually focus on task at hand.

Comparing Team Fortress 2 and Overwatch Art Direction
11 September, 2017
Opinion

Xavier Coelho-Kostolny took Twitter by surprise, giving his take on character design in two popular online shooters.

You might have heard of Xavier Coelho-Kostolny. He’s an amazing character artist, wonderful designer and great mentor (check out his Patreon). A couple of days ago, Xavier did an epic thread on Twitter, starting to compare the art direction of two of the most successful shooters in the world Team Fortress 2 and Overwatch. It’s amazing and we give a little transcript here, so you could read it in full. But do yourself a favor and subscribe to Xavier.

Let’s talk about art direction in Team Fortress 2 and Overwatch. This is just going to be regarding vanilla TF2, mind you. No hats and goofy costumes.

Team Fortress 2

So what makes TF2 good? Easy. It’s consistent through and through. Take a look at this comparison image of TF2 heads and think about what you see.

Really break down these heads, and you’ll find a ton of little nuances that keep everything within a consistent style.

For example, compare the angles of every nose to every forehead. With only minor tweaks/variations, the angles always match. With small choices like nose-forehead angle consistency, the artists build a consistent style which they can easily replicate. Similarly, look at the color palette.

Top is skin, primary team colors, secondary colors, and tertiary colors. Bottom is metals.

 

With this tightly restricted palette, the artists build patterns and variation while maintaining strict control to keep consistency. These colors stretch not just across characters and weapons, but across the environment as well.

Limiting the palette forces the artists to use shape language and materials to define different areas of the map. As a direct result, the two teams end up having distinct identities despite being functionally identical. Additionally, this identity makes gameplay more fluid by ensuring players always know where they are by distinct landmarks. This environmental design also pulls double duty by accentuating the identities of each team member.

If we look at this early screenshot, we can easily determine who is on which team at a glance.

The cool tones of the Heavy in the foreground contrast with the colors of the red base and the red team members. Instantly readable. This means you’re always going to know when the dude in your base is on your team or the enemy team. Their colors ALWAYS contrast. The shape language example from earlier also plays into character design by making silhouettes recognizable, even partially obscured. With distinct character silhouettes, you get instant readability. Take the heavy, for example. Even mostly cut off, still recognizable.

Now, with those things in mind, let’s look at some stuff from Overwatch.

Overwatch

What does Overwatch do well? Material reads, silhouettes, character recognizability. Even with different skins, they’re distinct.

However, we quickly run into problems! For example, which team are these characters on?

Is Genji throwing stuff at Sombra because he’s on a different team, or is he throwing PAST her?

By contrast, what happens if we shift some colors? Suddenly we get a better understanding of what’s happening in the image.

This same principle seems to apply to most screenshots, marketing or no. Even with good silhouettes, team readability is tough.

Part of the problem stems from not having distinct teams, despite OW’s built in fiction of Overwatch vs… everybody else. Considering the roots of Overwatch’s style AND gameplay, it’s odd to me that things as simple as team colors are not standard.

But wait! Overwatch HAS team colors!

Does it though? What happens when we switch the HUD colors? Which team is Pharah on now?

This highlights a fundamental principle of team-based games. Specifically, who’s on your team and who’s not.

In this case, Overwatch’s main theme— two teams battling for control of a map — becomes muddled. Despite the fact that these characters are all instantly recognizable by their silhouettes, they become unreadable next to each other.

Their overall designs, while solid and displaying fundamentally good character design principles, fall apart in a group.

Contrast the above with the almost exact same image from TF2.

Even with an extremely limited palette, TF2 designs remain distinct. Why?

The cause is twofold: 1. TF2 designs have larger areas of visual rest. 2. TF2 characters have a much stricter value hierarchy.

This value hierarchy shows itself in the use of illustrative rendering and by specifically painting color gradients into characters.

While the Overwatch designs are clean, they rarely show this value hierarchy, and thus become difficult to read.

Lucio, Junkrat, Roadhog, Soldier 76, all these characters fail to establish strict definition between light and dark values.

Additionally, many of these characters have areas of visual noise that do not read well at a distance.

However, there is one standout character in Overwatch that bucks this trend directly. Like it or not, she’s also the face of Overwatch. While I’m not a huge fan, Tracer is the strongest character design in the game by leaps and bounds. She’s the strongest because, out of all the characters in that group shot, she’s the only one with a readable silhouette.

This brings us back to value hierarchy. It brings us to the understanding that her bright yellow tights highlight her function: She’s fast as fuck, and her design accentuates that in every way. Her legs are impossibly long, and her design is sleek. And the thing that makes her design readable is the huge splash of color with a single gradient going across it.

This is something every other character lacks, to some degree, and the main reason they don’t read well.

Conclusion

So, to tighten the visuals of Overwatch and make the characters function better in gameplay, they all need to take a lesson from Tracer.

Eliminate the small details, or bring their values closer together. Use those huge splashes of color to differentiate characters.

Introduce team colors and eliminate colored nametags and visuals will be cleaner.

And consider giving more visual identity to different areas of maps to accentuate when you’re in the wrong neighborhood.

And there you have it. Xavier has some very interesting points. Don’t get us wrong, Overwatch is a great looking game, but some things still work better in TF2. Also, if you have the Orange Box, make sure to launch TF2 with some developer commentaries. It’s super interesting and it talk about characters as well.

Here’ a nice comment from Steffen Unger.

Xavier I totally agree on your points and see where you are coming from. However, taking marketing shots to make your point was a weak decision. Overwatch never has the problem of not knowing who your enemy is, because they use pretty simple readable post effects on the characters. You still instantly know who is who, what there function is and on which side there on. 

One could argue that some of the Ult colors are odd choices (using red for your teams raging Winston might not be the easiest to read at first glance). The recolorings are ugly to say the least, bland monochrome designs and in that regard, yes TF2 does work better and look better on a Red vs. Blue Level. That said, Halo does what you argue for, they color the teams entirely in one color. Making them blue and red blobs ultimately, so you instantly know who is who. However, i think it is a weird decision considering how much work goes into the design and execution of those skins. 

A system like in Overwatch would work a ton better visually (to me) while not destroying the readability. #TLDR i agree, gameplay first. But it can be achieved by more measures than just coloring the textures of a certain character.

Comments

Leave a Reply

6 Comments on "Comparing Team Fortress 2 and Overwatch Art Direction"

avatar
theuglymanowar
Guest
theuglymanowar
geez? I don’t play any game without a single player narrative rich campaign anymore ( heard overwatch had a temp special storied campaign awhile back but I missed it ) So this is just a guess… But could there possibly a big difference between PC and Console versions? And/Or A settings options that allows for/or are absent of? The Team Colored Outline as a preference? Otherwise thats a pretty obvious and varied discrepancy in the experience. ( not that I would agree or disagree on team color design considerations as being penultimate? For someone that might desire immersive realism above… Read more »
Bayonetwork
Guest
Bayonetwork

dduane117@yahoo.com, what are you talking about? Enemies has red outlines in the game unlike in those screenshots.

Danila
Guest
Danila

I can not agree with the statements in this article, as an Overwatch player. The silhouettes are easy recognizable, it is nearly impossible to confuse enemy with the ally. And, for example, during Widowmaker ultimate ability you can easily tell who is the enemy hero just by the outline.

dhedhe_kuncoro@yahoo.com
Member
dhedhe_kuncoro@yahoo.com

Its best described by comparing it with a bad example *cough*Lawbreakers*cough*

dduane117@yahoo.com
Member
dduane117@yahoo.com
The images they’re using as reference are representative of the final product of Overwatch. Played the game a week ago and this is exactly what it looks like. Unless there have been some extreme changes within the last week, then this image is a fine representation of OW. And speaking as someone who plays the game, I cannot easily distinguish between characters based on silhouettes, especially if they’re wearing a special skin that alters their original silhouette. It’s an issue I have in multiple games too. Overwatch. Battlefield 1. R6: Seige. Chivalry: MW. All of them have a tough time… Read more »
Tom
Guest
Tom
Why are you looking at Overwatch pictures that are over a year old from the Beta and not at all representative of the final product? The enemy team has red outlines, distinguishing which team a player is on is never an issue in Overwatch, ever. Have you even played the game? Everyone that plays the game can easily distinguish between characters based on silhouette, no matter what skin they have. Saying Tracer is the only one with a readable silhouette is rubbish. I thought this site had some quality control before publishing articles. I don’t mind you critiquing the game,… Read more »
wpDiscuz