The Binding of Isaac Creator on Its Staying Power & Ideas for His Games
We asked Edmund McMillen about his decision to release The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ on consoles the same day as GTA 6, the changes since the 2011 Flash game, and the process of coming up with new ideas for his projects.
The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ will be released on Switch 2, PS5, and Xbox on November 19, the same day as another very popular game. We talked to Isaac's creator, Edmund McMillen, to see how confident he is about the staying power of the game and what's next for him after the launch.
Edmund, even though you've developed multiple games, including Super Meat Boy and Mewgenics, you are most associated with The Binding of Isaac. Does it bother or flatter you? Do you think you will ever create a game that will overshadow TBOI in this sense?
I mean, of course, I can't deny that Isaac has become something much bigger than myself and my other work. We sold nearly 5 million copies of the game this year. It's insane the amount of staying power that game has, and I'm sure I'll be the Binding of Isaac guy till I die at this point.
That said, I do think Mewgenics is on par with Isaac, and maybe after a few years of DLCs I can be known as the Mewgenics guy as well!
Isaac has changed a lot since its 2011 Flash game. When you look at Repentance+ now, how much of the original is still there, and what parts would you not recognize?
I think at its core the Flash game is still very, very much in there at the heart of everything; in fact, I think Repentance is closer to the Flash version than Rebirth was. Vinh [Truong, designer and programmer] took a lot of time to go back to the original and bring out anything missed in the initial remake, made it more punishing and interesting in subtle ways that felt a lot like the Flash version.
The biggest changes or evolutions were probably the game's story, pushing more into why Mom is who Isaac sees her as, and then looping back into the game’s original themes of religious dogma and how it can affect an outcast child from a broken home.
What do you think makes Isaac stay popular after all these years, aside from its replayability? What urges players to return to it again and again?
I really don’t know for sure. It's weird; it stays with you. The gameplay loop feels nice, and there is a lot you can do? I'd like to say it has stood the test of time simply because it was fun and the themes are completely unique when put next to anything else being offered in video games? There is a very human element to the core of Isaac that I think a lot of my fellow outcasts out there can relate to. I hope so anyway.
Now that you've built on the game so much, do you disagree with some of your early design or gameplay decisions? How drastically has your perspective changed over the years?
I mean, really, the main thing was item descriptions. The game has needed those for years, and they were on the to-do list, but mods existed, so we decided to focus on content rather than QOF stuff. But I'm very happy console players can have that now. Not much else has changed; maybe trying to rebalance the more shitty items so they are useful?
You called Repentance the last DLC, but then we got Repentance+. Will we ever see another one? What if fans create a mod as massive as Antibirth, which became a part of the official game, will you think about returning to TBOI, or is it the final version for sure?
This is the final version of the game. That said, if I get the wild hare to add something neat, or Nicalis wants to do something fun as they did with multiplayer... I'm not closing the door on that aspect of the game! THIS IS THE LAST DLC! Kinda.
How do you decide when the game needs revisiting and when it's time to move on? Do you feel a sense of closure with Isaac?
I have no idea... I'm bad at putting down ideas I love; I’m literally working on 2 Mewgenics updates as I type this...
I feel great about where Isaac is. I think a lot of people consider it a classic at this point, and that’s surreal to realize.
How do you usually come up with new items and ideas for your games? Have you ever thought that a Mewgenics idea would work better in Issac?
Usually its 2 ways. One is literally what would be interesting thematically to design around, like giving Isaac brittle bone disease – how can I turn that into a mechanic? The other is taking an archetype like self-damage and designing something that fits into that slot. Both are pretty spontaneous, honestly.
I haven't had any Mewgenics ideas that would convert well to Isaac since action and turn-based themes don’t speak well when you take them from turn-based to action. But a HELL of a lot of Isaac mechanics made their way into Mewgenics perfectly.
Repentance+ is coming to Switch 2, PS5, and Xbox on November 19, the same day as GTA 6. I'd say most developers moved their releases away from the entire month, but you are not afraid to compete for attention with what players call the most anticipated game ever. Do you believe in Isaac’s staying power that much, or is there another reason?
Yes, I think we are going to totally crush GTA 6! JUST WAIT, ROCKSTAR! I GOT A NAKED BALD KID WITH YOUR NAME ON IT!
What are your plans for after November 19? Will you continue working on Mewgenics, or do you already have another idea in mind?
Yeah, I'm working on a substantial update to Mewgenics that should be out by the end of the year. We are also juggling a larger paid DLC that should come out by the end of next year, but it's already ballooning, so don't hold me to that!
I'd love to do a small game in the middle somewhere, but for now I've only got cats on my mind.